Colorado

Aspen vs Crested Butte: Which Colorado Town Fits Your Trip

Aspen vs Crested Butte: a silver town with four ski mountains and big festivals or a low-key wildflower and mountain bike town. Compare skiing, food and stays.

The short answer

Pick Aspen if you want four ski mountains, a deep fine dining list and a calendar of music, ideas and food festivals in a historic silver town. Pick Crested Butte if you want wildflowers, mountain biking and steep skiing in a small, low-key town where bikes outnumber cars in summer.

At a glance

TopicAspenCrested Butte
Best forFour ski mountains, fine dining and summer festivalsWildflowers, mountain biking and steep skiing
Elevation7,908 feet8,885 feet in town, 9,375 feet in Mount Crested Butte
From Denver200 miles, about four hours230 miles, about four and a half hours
Getting aroundOn foot, with free RFTA buses in town and to SnowmassFree Mountain Express bus every 15 minutes, 7 AM to midnight
Where to stayThe base of Aspen Mountain, downtown or the West EndThe historic town on Elk Avenue or Mt. Crested Butte
Best timeJanuary and February for skiing, the last two weeks of September for aspensMid-July for wildflowers, early February for powder

The feel of each town

Aspen was a silver camp first. Prospectors struck ore in 1879, and the Hotel Jerome and the Wheeler Opera House from the 1880s still stand. After the silver boom ended in 1893, Walter Paepcke arrived in 1945 and built the Aspen Institute and the Aspen Music Festival. The wealth is visible, and so is the town's investment in culture and public land. About 7,400 people live there year-round. Crested Butte was founded in 1880 as a coal mining town. Skiing arrived in 1961, bringing the hippies and ski bums whose counterculture still defines it. Its downtown is three blocks of Elk Avenue lined with colorful Victorians, and its guide calls the people there younger and more hands-on than in Aspen. Read our Aspen guide and our Crested Butte guide.

Skiing and the mountains

Aspen skiing spreads across four mountains: Aspen Mountain, Aspen Highlands, Buttermilk and Snowmass. The mountain averages 300 inches a year, concentrated January through March. The Aspen guide says Snowmass has better intermediate terrain and shorter lift lines, and the free bus from Rubey Park gets you there in 20 minutes. Bonnie's, on Aspen Mountain, has served skiers since the 1960s. Crested Butte Mountain Resort sits three miles above town, with a season from late November through early April and an average of 236 inches of snow. The Extremes are some of the steepest inbounds runs in North America. On a powder day, the guide suggests the Silver Queen chair first. Compare more mountains in our list of the best ski towns in Colorado.

Summer and the outdoors

In Aspen, the Maroon Bells are the big summer draw, and in season you need a reservation to get there. Independence Pass, the gondola and the free Aspen Art Museum fill out a trip, and Smuggler Mountain Road gains 1,000 feet in two miles to a view over the valley. The Aspen Music Festival runs late June through late August. Crested Butte is the Wildflower Capital of Colorado, with over 200 species blooming from mid-July through early August. A 1976 ride from Crested Butte over Pearl Pass to Aspen is considered one of the origin points of mountain biking, and August is prime time for riding. See things to do in Aspen, things to do in Crested Butte and our Crested Butte summer guide.

Food and drink

Aspen has a deep fine dining list. Bosq says it earned Aspen's first Michelin star and offers a five-course tasting at $215. Matsuhisa opened in 1998 in a Main Street Victorian house, with an eight-course omakase at $195. Cache Cache has been in Aspen since 1987, and Paradise Bakery has baked its cookies from scratch since 1976. Crested Butte keeps things casual. Slogar serves a family-style fried chicken dinner and says it has done so for well over 40 years. Secret Stash makes specialty pizzas for $25 or $35, and Teocalli Tamale has been open since 1997. For a special night, Soupçon has seated 28 guests at a time since 1975. Many restaurants in both towns close between seasons, so check before you go.

Where to stay

Aspen is small enough to walk. Stay at the base of Aspen Mountain to be close to the gondola, downtown for the restaurants and history, or in the West End for quiet and the summer music festival. The holiday window between December 23 and January 2 is the most expensive and crowded time. Crested Butte has two bases: the historic town on Elk Avenue, and Mt. Crested Butte, the ski area base about three miles up the road, with a free shuttle between them. Choose from small inns and bed and breakfasts, condo-style lodges at the lifts, or cabins outside town, and book months ahead for peak weeks. Compare where to stay in Aspen, where to stay in Crested Butte and our guide to where to stay in Colorado.

Getting there and getting around

Aspen is 200 miles west of Denver, about four hours via I-70 to Glenwood Springs, then Highway 82 south. Independence Pass is the scenic route from the east, open Memorial Day weekend through mid-October, and it tops out at 12,095 feet. Pitkin County Airport sits four miles from downtown, though flights are weather-dependent. In town, the RFTA bus is free. Crested Butte is 230 miles southwest of Denver, about four and a half hours via I-70 to Highway 50 through Gunnison, and the most scenic approach crosses Monarch Pass at 11,312 feet. The Gunnison-Crested Butte Regional Airport is 30 miles south, and the Alpine Express shuttle takes 40 minutes. The free Mountain Express bus covers town and the ski base. For more routes, see our Colorado drives.

When to go

Aspen's guide points to January and February for skiing, with the first two weeks of March as a sweet spot. The last two weeks of September are its best time overall, with aspens peaking between September 20 and October 5 in a typical year. The X Games run the last weekend of January, and the Food & Wine Classic is the third weekend in June. Crested Butte's guide points to mid-July for wildflowers and early February for powder, with Vinotok, a harvest festival, in mid-September. Both towns have spring and fall mud seasons when many businesses close, and both guides warn about crowds and high prices over the Christmas holidays. Check our Colorado events calendar before you book.

Which one to pick

Pick Aspen if you want four mountains on one trip, a long list of fine dining, and a summer of music and ideas festivals in a town with deep history and visible wealth. It is the slightly shorter drive, at about four hours from Denver, and sits at 7,908 feet. Pick Crested Butte if wildflowers, mountain biking or steep skiing come first, and you prefer a small, low-key town where people value time outside over visible wealth. It is about four and a half hours from Denver, at 8,885 feet. The two towns share a piece of history through the 1976 Pearl Pass ride. For more ideas around the state, see things to do in Colorado.

Questions people ask

Is Aspen or Crested Butte better for skiing?

They offer different trips. Aspen gives you four mountains, Aspen Mountain, Aspen Highlands, Buttermilk and Snowmass, and averages 300 inches of snow a year. Crested Butte is one resort, three miles above town, with an average of 236 inches a year. Its Extremes are some of the steepest inbounds runs in North America and typically open in mid-January.

Which is closer to Denver, Aspen or Crested Butte?

Aspen is a little closer. It is 200 miles west of Denver, about four hours via I-70 to Glenwood Springs and Highway 82. Crested Butte is 230 miles southwest, about four and a half hours via I-70 to Highway 50 through Gunnison. Pitkin County Airport sits four miles from downtown Aspen, and the Gunnison-Crested Butte Regional Airport is 30 miles south of Crested Butte.

How are Aspen and Crested Butte connected?

Through a bike ride. In 1976, Crested Butte locals rode single-speed cruiser bikes over Pearl Pass to Aspen for a party. The Crested Butte guide says that ride is considered one of the origin points of mountain biking, and the Mountain Bike Hall of Fame is in Crested Butte. Today, August is prime time for riding there.

Is Aspen or Crested Butte at a higher elevation?

Crested Butte is higher. The town sits at 8,885 feet and Mount Crested Butte at 9,375 feet. Aspen sits at 7,908 feet. Both guides say you will likely feel it at first, so drink plenty of water and skip alcohol on the first night. The Aspen guide suggests asking your doctor about Diamox if you are altitude sensitive.

Do you need a car in Aspen or Crested Butte?

Not in town. Aspen's RFTA bus system is free within Aspen and runs to Snowmass, Basalt, Carbondale and Glenwood Springs, and parking garages in the core run $15 to $30 per day. Crested Butte's free Mountain Express bus links town and Mount Crested Butte every 15 minutes from 7 AM to midnight. Rent a car there for the 401 or Kebler Pass.

When do the aspens peak in Aspen and Crested Butte?

Aspen's guide calls the last two weeks of September the best time of year, with aspens peaking between September 20 and October 5 in a typical year and higher elevations turning first. Around Crested Butte, the Kebler Pass aspens peak from late September to early October, and the last two weeks of September bring firm bike trails and a quiet town.

Get the Colorado email.

What's on, where to go and where to stay. Free.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.